Homemade Cookies that Innovate!
Come try some of the many homemade delights offered by the Tasty Bev and Treatery! From the classic chocolate chip cookie to its updated lava cookie cousin, and scrumptious peanut butter cookies that melt in your mouth, making delicious cookies is what we do best! Here you will see the list of cookie options on our menu, sorted by standard cookies, allergy-friendly options, and sugar-free options.
Please feel free to reach out to us if you need something different, or just to add something to what we have! We can add M&Ms, make a giant chocolate chip cookie made out to your lovie, or have samplers made to hand out to your family, friends, and peers. For the month of November, the new cookie was a special request... the Orange Cranberry Cookie.
This is the Chocolate Chip Lava Cookie!
Oh My!!
The New Orange Cranberry Cookie!
| Standard Cookies | Price |
|---|---|
| Chocolate Cherry Delight Cookies (chocolate cookies with coconut and cherry, topped with vanilla frosting, a beautiful maraschino cherry, and chocolate drizzle) | US $11.00 per dozen or US $5.50 per half dozen |
| Chocolate Chip Cookies | US $8.00 per dozen or US $4.00 per half dozen |
| Chocolate Chip Lava Cookies (a chocolate chip cookie filled with a core of soft fudgy deliciousness) | US $10.00 per dozen or US $5.00 per half dozen |
| Oatmeal Raisin Cookies or Oatmeal Apple Cranberry Cookies | US $8.00 per dozen or US $10.00 per dozen iced US $4.00 / $5.00 per half dozen |
| Orange Cranberry Cookie (made with the zest and juice of a naval orange, and sweetened dried or fresh cranberries... drizzled with an orange glaze) | US $9.00 per dozen or US $4.50 per half dozen |
| Peanut Butter Cookies | US $7.00 per dozen or US $3.50 per half dozen |
| Pumpkin Snickerdoodles (See snickerdoodles below, but with real pumpkin) | US $10.00 per dozen or US $5.00 per half dozen |
| Ranger Cookies (Oatmeal, Coconut, Various Fruits) | US $9.00 per dozen or US $4.50 per half dozen |
| Snickerdoodles (Sugar Cookie Variety rolled in Cinnamon Sugar) | US $9.00 per dozen or US $4.50 per half dozen |
| Stuffed Snickerdoodles (Contact me for options, but currently have a pumpkin cheesecake filling highlighted for the season) | US $11.00 per dozen or US $5.50 per half dozen |
| Sugar Cookies (Round, Unfrosted) | US $7.00 per dozen or US $3.50 per half dozen |
| Sugar Cookies (Shaped, Frosted), 2-3 inches depending on the shape | US $1.25 each |
| Snack Packs - 3 cookie packages that can be the same or mixed. | US $2.00 - $2.50 each - Please call |
Chocolate Chip Cookies, Peanut Butter Cookies, Ranger Cookies, and Chocolate Cherry Delights
| Allergy Friendly Cookies (no dairy, gluten, nuts, or soy unless indicated by **) | Price |
|---|---|
| Chocolate Cherry Delight Cookies (normally contains coconut)** | US $13.00 per dozen or US $6.50 per half dozen |
| Chocolate Chip Cookies | US $11.00 per dozen or US $5.50 per half dozen |
| Chocolate Chip Lava Cookies (a chocolate chip cookie filled with a core of soft fudgy deliciousness - made with chips free from 12 common allergens) | US $13.00 per dozen or US $6.50 per half dozen |
| Oatmeal Raisin Cookies or Oatmeal Apple Cranberry Cookies | US $10.00 per dozen or US $12.00 per dozen iced US $5.00 per half dozen / US $6.00 iced |
| Orange Cranberry Cookie (made with the zest and juice of a naval orange, and sweetened dried or fresh cranberries... drizzled with an orange glaze) | US $11.00 per dozen or US $5.50 per half dozen |
| Pumpkin Snickerdoodles (See snickerdoodles below, but with real pumpkin) | US $12.00 per dozen or US $6.00 per half dozen |
| Ranger Cookies (Oatmeal, Coconut, Various Fruits)** | US $9.00 per dozen or US $4.50 per half dozen |
| Snickerdoodles (Sugar Cookie Variety rolled in Cinnamon Sugar) | US $11.00 per dozen or US $5.50 per half dozen |
| Sugar Cookies (Round, Unfrosted) | US $9.00 per dozen or US $4.50 per half dozen |
| Sugar Cookies (Shaped, Frosted), 2-3 inches depending on the shape | US $1.50 each |
| Snack Packs - 3 cookie packages that can be the same or mixed. | US $3.00 - $3.50 each - Please call |
Allergy Friendly Chocolate Cherry Delight Cookies, Chocolate Chip Cookies, and Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
| Sugar Free Cookies | Price |
|---|---|
| Chocolate Chip Cookies - even the chips are sugar free! | US $11.00 per dozen or US $5.50 per half dozen |
| Chocolate Chip Lava Cookies | US $13.00 per dozen or US $6.50 per half dozen |
| Oatmeal Raisin Cookies or Oatmeal Apple Cranberry Cookies | US $9.50 per dozen or US $4.75 per half dozen |
| Peanut Butter Cookies | US $8.50 per dozen or US $4.25 per half dozen |
| Pumpkin Snickerdoodles (See snickerdoodles below, but with real pumpkin) | US $11.50 per dozen or US $5.75 per half dozen |
| Snickerdoodles (Sugar Cookie Variety rolled in Cinnamon Sugar) | US $10.50 per dozen or US $5.25 per half dozen |
| Sugar Cookies (Round, Unfrosted) | US $8.50 per dozen or US $4.25 per half dozen |
| Snack Packs - 3 cookie packages that can be the same or mixed. | US $3.00 - $3.50 each - Please call |
| Please note that my sugar free cookies will have some minor textural differences from the standard cookies. Let me know if you have a preference for Stevia, Swerve, Allulose, Date Sugar, etc... each brings something different in terms of taste and how natural its processing is. Some people can really taste the difference. Call for me for questions! I can make a recommendation for you. |
Don't need it fully allergy friendly or sugar free?
If you only need a partial modification, such as a vegan peanut butter cookie, then just give me a call. It is $2-3 more per dozen of fully allergy friendly cookies due to the cost of the ingredients. Just vegan (dairy-free) or just gluten free will run about $1 more.
Same with sugar free... if you want a reduced sugar cookie, I can make fruited cookies with Allulose or Stevia, and the only source of sugar is from the fruit. Very helpful to maintain a healthy diet.
A new modification is my low-octane cookies where the recipe uses half sugar and half sugar-substitute... the results are amazing! If you want that for your order, just tell me.
Finally, if you greatly desire to have nuts, just ask. It's not standard on my menu, but I will use another kitchen to make it just for you! Walnuts, pecans, macadamia... just tell me! The White Chocolate Chip Macadamia Nut Cookie with Dried Cranberries is to die for!